Skip to main content

Companion planting - myth or reality?

I've heard of companion planting and read about people using it on a few blogs (here and here and here), but due to a general lack of planning in my garden anyway, I hadn't got around to implementing it myself yet.  It has also been pointed out to me that I one of the reasons my peas didn't succeed this season is because I planted them next to spring onions, so I have been thinking about paying more attention to companion planting.
The peas don't like growing with the onions, but why??
Part of the reason I haven't taken a huge interest in companion planting so far is an uneasiness about the science behind it.  I don't like to just blindly follow instructions about which plants like to grow together, I like to know why something works, so I can modify the system to work for me in my garden.  For example, with the peas, I assumed that the reason for not planting peas and onions was that the nitrogen from the peas will make the onions too leafy with not enough growth underground, however if I'm growing spring onions then it would be ok.  I don't see how the onions can impact the peas, but maybe there's some plant/soil chemistry interaction that I don't know about, see how I need to know the WHY so I can make decisions!

Time for a bit of google research and I found a few interesting articles.....
Is Companion Planting Scientific?
The Myth of Companion Planting

The Art of Companion Planting

I can see that the reasons that companion planting may work, are varied and include:
  1. alleopathic interactions (both good and bad)
  2. confusing pests 
  3. preventing the spread of diseases
  4. enhancing environmental conditions for growth (mostly about shading young seedlings with wide-leaved plants)
The last three points can be achieved just by mixing up the garden in the way that I do now.  If there's a gap for a seedling I'll pop it in there and it will be shaded by other plants, which will be pulled out eventually, leaving more room for the seedling to develop.  The mixed up vegetables should also confuse pests and prevent the spread of diseases.  Some of the recommendations that come from the northern hemisphere for specific companions to deter pests up there may not help us down here in Australia, with different pests attacking our plants, so I'm happy to just use a general mix up, rather than stick to a plan.

Zucchinis and corn are supposed to like growing together, but can you see the corn?
I'm still a bit confused about how to also apply a rotation program, as this kind of depends on having similar plants in the same garden bed and moving them each year, how then do I mix them up?  (By the way, I love this post about garden planning strategies ).  

Anyway, the first point above is the interesting one, and requires more information to put it to use.
Allelopathy is a biological phenomenon by which an organism produces one or more biochemicals that influence the growth, survival, and reproduction of other organisms. These biochemicals are known as allelochemicals and can have beneficial (positive allelopathy) or detrimental (negative allelopathy) effects on the target organisms- Wikipedia
You really need to know the alleopathic interactions of each plant to know which can be planted together, and maybe that's why I had a problem with the peas next to the onions, but it seems that most of the research in this area has been targeted, as usual, at commercial applications for allelopathy - using the chemicals to develop herbicides.  Its so frustrating that this research effort is wasted when they could be working out how to grow vegetables in organic gardens/larger scale farms more efficiently!  Although I guess its pretty difficult to design an objective study of plant alllelopathy, so I should just use the associations that have been developed over the years based on experience and see what does work for me.

My next problem is finding a system that I want to follow.  As this post found out after comparing several different companion planting guides, they don't all agree!  They recommended that you at least consider the plants that are consistently reported to not grow well together and try to avoid those combinations, which includes peas and onions (damn!).  They have compiled a summary of several commonly used guides to assist.  There is also a summary table (which even includes some reasons for bad neighbours, I like it!!!) on this post from Sustainable Gardening Australia, which I think will be useful.  I have copied it into a word doc, deleted the veges that I don't usually grow and printed it out for easy reference in future (I almost need to laminate it and put it on the garden gate so I remember to use it!).

If you are interested in reading about other potential gardening myths, Linda Chalker-Scott has reviewed a number of them, with some interesting and well-researched articles on her website.

Do you use companion planting in your garden?  Does it work for you?

Comments

  1. Very interesting post. Thanks for this. I have no idea about companion plants either but I like the idea of it. Will have to wait and see if it works better.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi...I am a city girl thru and thru and have just bought 5 acres which I must admit have no idea what to do with ..it has a tiny 8 sq shack on it which is gorgeous, have emtpied that and upgrading inside, but then to start outside..wow...what a task.....so a big ty for sharing your information, I'm sure I will come to reply on it many times :)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Thanks, I appreciate all your comments, suggestions and questions, but I don't always get time to reply right away. If you need me to reply personally to a question, please leave your email address in the comment or in your profile, or email me directly on eight.acres.liz at gmail.com

Popular posts from this blog

What to do with eight acres

Behind the scenes of my blog I can see the search terms that led people to find my blog.  It can be quite interesting to look through them occasionally and see what people are looking for.  Most of them involve chicken tractors, but another question that comes up regularly is “what can you do with eight acres?” or “how much land is eight acres?”.  Today I will try to answer this question.

Of course it is a very broad question, there are lots and lots of things you can do with eight acres, but I’m going to assume that you want to live there, feed your family and maybe make a little extra money.  I make that assumption because that’s what I know about, if you want to do something else with your eight acres, you will need to look somewhere else.

If you haven’t chosen your land yet, here a few things to look for.  Focus on the things you can’t change and try to choose the best property you can find in your price range.  Look for clean water in dams, bores or wells, either on the property …

We don't have any cling wrap either

Last week I wrote about how we don't have a microwave and I really don't miss it.  So continuing the theme of "weird things about my kitchen", we also don't have any plastic cling wrap or paper towels.  And we haven't had them for so long I can hardly remember why we ever needed them.


I always thought that cling wrap was wasteful.  Not just from an environmental perspective, but I also didn't like spending money on something that I only used once.  When I was at uni and took sandwiches for lunch, I used to bring home the cling wrap and use it again until it didn't stick anymore.  One year when we did Plastic Free July (I can't remember when exactly - here's what I wrote last year) we decided to stop using cling wrap.  I used up the last of it recently when we were painting (its really hard to renovate without creating waste) - its handy for wrapping up paintbrushes and sealing paint temporarily, however I do not use it in the kitchen.

The pape…

Getting started with chickens - Tanya from Lovely Greens

Sign up for my weekly email updates here, you will find out more about soap and our farmlife, straight to your inbox, never miss a post!  New soap website and shop opening soon....

Farmer Liz: You will remember Tanya from Lovely Greens from the first series, she lives on the Isle of Mann and added chickens to her garden about a year ago.  You can leave comments for this post on Tanya's blog.



How many chickens (and other fowl) do you keep, what breed and what do you use them for (meat, eggs, slug control etc)?
Tanya: Around the same time that we were initially thinking about having hens another friend beat us to the punch. She went to the local pet store and bought a flat-pack hen house and chicken run combo and found a local farmer who had dozens of semi-feral chickens running around his property. One night he pulled three down from the trees and my friend took them home in a pet carrier. She named them Miracel, Carmen, and Geraldine and though they’re probably related they were all…