Skip to main content

Raw milk yoghurt attempts and failures

Since we got Bella last weekend, we have litres and litres of fresh cow's milk, so I tried to make some yoghurt.  I used my usual method of mixing a spoonful of the previous batch into some fresh milk (except before we got Bella, I used milk powder instead) and put the container in my Easiyo thermos to set.  Most recipes to say to pasturise (heat) the milk before making yoghurt, but I have also read that making the yoghurt from raw (unheated) milk allows more beneficial bacteria to grow, so I wanted to try that instead.

Bella is producing about 6 L of milk a day for us
 and still feeding her calf
Unfortunately the result was very disappointing, the whey separated and the yoghurt was thin and very sour.  It wasn't at all appetising, so I fed it to the dogs, they loved it, and tried again.  Same result.  Time to do some reading.  I read every cheese/yoghurt making book we own (4 now!) and everything I could find on the internet (see this one in particular).
It seems there are many many options and conflicting advice when it comes to making yoghurt!
  • Start with raw milk or pasturised milk
  • Warm milk (30degC) or leave it at room temperature
  • Thermos or heating pad to keep it at incubation temp
  • Inoculation by previous batch of yoghurt or by freeze-dried bacteria
By the end of it, all I knew was that raw milk at room temp, in a thermos of boiling water, using yoghurt didn't work, even though it works for other people, so I was doing SOMETHING wrong, but no idea what.

My goal is to work out how to make nice yoghurt with raw milk, but I suspect that might have been my problem, as you don't know what else is in the milk that's conflicting with the yoghurt bacteria.  Last night I heated the milk to 90degC and then cooled to 40degC.  I added my previous yoghurt (1 teaspoon) and incubated in the thermos.

This morning, to my great relief, I had perfect yoghurt in the jar.  But I'm not impressed about the heat treatment - both the time involved and the fact that heating it is killing all the goodness in the raw milk, I may as well just use milk powder!  At least I still have yoghurt to eat while I figure out my next move and the dogs don't mind eating my failures!

So I will continue in my quest to perfect raw milk yoghurt, any advice would be much appreciated!

eight acres: trying to make raw milk yoghurt
The yoghurt worked, but only with heat treated milk,
I want to make it with raw milk!
For the latest on my yoghurt making techniques, see here.

You might also be interested in my series on getting started with homestead dairy
Labels:

Comments

  1. BPheasantMay 27, 2011 at 1:26 PM

    Design of Experiments - can't believe I remember terms like that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. BeckyMay 27, 2011 at 6:19 PM

    Sounds like you are up for the challenge - I'm afraid I would have given up after the first try. May you find the "perfect" mix soon.

    ReplyDelete
  3. TammyMay 29, 2011 at 1:23 PM

    Hi Liz. Good luck with the yoghurt making.
    I started a conversation up about your fire in the Down to Earth Forum, well the conversation started as I was trying to find your blog and couldn't ... but I was looking for your fire to show another member. Just letting you know. :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. UnknownMay 29, 2011 at 5:57 PM

    No worries Tammy, thanks for letting me know as it reminded me that I haven't had a good look at that forum yet (if anyone else is interested, its at http://downtoearthforums.com/forum.php). Cheers, Liz

    ReplyDelete
  5. calliecatMay 30, 2011 at 3:23 AM

    it was for me - love the fire :)
    CC

    ReplyDelete
  6. SuziJune 1, 2011 at 8:15 PM

    I've only ever heard about yoghurt making as a heating and cooling thing.. mind you, they first came about yoghurt when they were using a sheep's stomach to transport milk and it turned. So I have a feeling you may need to only use yoghurt making bacteria from animal gut (or synthesized) to reproduce this.
    Why don't you have a go at making cheese, the French make it from raw milk all the time.
    xx so interesting!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. JohnandJeanMay 12, 2013 at 8:32 AM

    I've got a feeling that the problem is the starter not being strong enough. Have you tried a shop bought freeze dried starter? We just dissolve the granules in the milk as it is brought to the right temperature. Stir for at least 1-3 minutes to ensure the granules dissolve and the batch is well mixed.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Thanks, I appreciate all your comments, suggestions and questions, but I don't always get time to reply right away. If you need me to reply personally to a question, please leave your email address in the comment or in your profile, or email me directly on eight.acres.liz at gmail.com

Popular posts from this blog

Farm update - August 2017

Its been cold this month, and very nice to have the fire going every night.  Here's a photo of my boy in his cape, great for late night woofing at things.  Most of July we were either preparing for the butcher to come or putting meat away.  Its always a big job, but its only once a year, and its all done now.  My lovely neighbour came over to help, so it was fun to have the company and work together.  Taz was a champion once again as she helped us to move cattle in the yards ready to load for the market.  Gus is not at that level yet and had to stay home (he cries when he gets left behind, but he just gets in the way and scatters the cattle).  We have had a few sprinkles of rain here and there, but also plenty of cold nights, so the grass is mostly dead and dry, waiting for the warmer weather to revive our summer-active pasture. Gus in his cape Taz after she helped to move cattle Food and cooking It was all about beef in July and we are v...
2 comments
Read more

Cooking and eating beans

When I was growing up, my family never ate many dried beans, they just weren't something that was used much in NZ cuisine.  If I did eat beans, it was always from a can (and most likely baked beans).  And until recently I was still using beans from a can, but it can be difficult to get organic beans, and to find cans not lined with BPA.  Then I had an opportunity to buy some organic dry goods in bulk, so I bought 5kg of kidney beans, 5kg of adzuki beans and 5kg of chickpea (garbanzo beans).  I know, that is a lot of beans.  And then I didn't really know what to do with them!  Not just what dishes to put them in, but how to prepare them, I just didn't know what method to use. So I decided it was time to learn how to use all these beans that I bought, here's what I found out. I started with an excellent ebook called The Everything Beans Book , from Katie at Kitchen Stewardship, which has lots of bean recipes, but more importantly, an explanation of h...
12 comments
Read more

Guest post: Is there a place for power tools in the garden?

One of my regular readers and commenters offered to write a guest post about a horticulture course, its quite a funny read, with some serious insights into our technology obsession.  If you'd like to submit a guest post, email me at eight.acres.liz {at} gmail.com.  While I am always happy to share links back to your blog or website, this contributor preferred to remain anonymous.  I hope you enjoy their story.... -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**-  -**- Just a few days ago our daily horticulture classes were interrupted by an invitation to review some new gardening gadgets. The idea was to open half a dozen of electric hand trimmers , test them and fill in some review about their goods and bads. As nothing is more dear to a student – even a “hort “ one - to escape routine and mess around till lunchtime, we opened the boxes and got down to business. What did we...
8 comments
Read more